A half
serving of soy-based foods a day may significantly lower a man’s sperm count,
according to new research.
Previous animal
studies have linked large amounts of soy isoflavones to infertility. Isoflavones,
sometimes called phytoestrogens, are compounds that mimic the effects of
estrogen. However, little human research has been performed in this area. This recent
study, presented at the 63rd Annual Meeting of the American Society for
Reproductive Medicine, is believed to be the largest human trial to examine the
relationship between semen quality and isoflavones.
The
researchers analyzed the soy intake of 100 men who went to fertility clinics
between 2000 and 2006. The men provided
semen samples and answered questions about how often they ate soy-rich foods,
such as tofu, tempeh, and soy milk, in the last three months.
Because
different foods contain different amounts of isoflavones, the researchers set a
standard for serving sizes of particular foods. For instance, one serving of
soy was equivalent to two cups of soy milk and one soya burger. The subjects
were then divided into different groups based on the amount of soy they ate.
On
average, the men in the highest intake group ate a half serving of soy per day.
These men had an average of 65 million sperm per milliliter of ejaculate, which
was about 40 percent less than men who ate no soy foods. A normal sperm count
ranges from 80 million to 120 million per milliliter, while 20 million per
milliliter or below is considered low.
The
association was strongest in overweight men, suggesting that hormones may be
involved. This is because overweight men produce higher levels of
androgen-produced estrogen than healthy men.
However, it
is unclear if soy intake affects aspects of male health, such as fertility. It
is possible that other behaviors, besides soy intake, influenced the results
because this was an observation trial. Larger studies are needed to determine
if soy foods should be avoided in men trying to conceive.
Soy
manufacturers caution that these findings contradict earlier studies that found
soy has no impact on sperm count.
For more
information about soy, please visit Natural Standard’s Foods, Herbs & Supplements
database.