A recent
study supports growing evidence that eating too much meat may be unhealthy.
Researchers from the U.S. National Cancer Institute found that a diet rich in
red and processed meats increased the risk of death, particularly from cancer
and heart disease.
In the
study, published in the Archives of Internal Medicine, researchers
analyzed data from more than half a million people (aged 50-71) who were
enrolled in the National Institutes of Health-AARP Diet and Health Study. Meat
intake was estimated through a food questionnaire.
People in
the high-intake group for red meat ate an average of 4.5 ounces daily, while
those in the lowest-intake group ate a little more than half an ounce daily.
For processed meat, people in the high-intake group ate an average of 1.5
ounces daily compared to 0.11 ounces in the low-intake group.
During the
10-year follow-up period, the researchers recorded the number of deaths and
their causes. They adjusted for other risk factors, such as age, smoking,
obesity and alcohol consumption.
By the end
of the study, 47,976 men and 23,276 women died from various causes. In those
who ate the most red meat, the overall risk of death increased by 31 percent in
men and 36 percent in women, compared to those who ate the least. The risk of
fatal cancer increased by 22 percent in men and 20 percent in women, and the
risk of fatal heart disease increased by 27 percent in men and 50 percent in
women.
In those who
ate the most processed meat, the overall risk of death increased by 16 percent
in men and 25 percent in women, compared to those who ate the least. The risk
of fatal cancer increased by 12 percent in men and 11 percent in women, while
the risk of fatal heart disease increased by nine percent in men and 38 percent
in women.
In contrast,
people who ate higher proportions of white meat, such as turkey, chicken or
fish, were less likely to die during the study period than those who ate the
lowest proportions.
These
results are somewhat limited by the study design because the data relied on the
participants' memories of what they ate.
It has been
suggested that cancer risk may be increased by compounds called heterocyclic
amines (HCAs), which are formed when red meat is cooked at high temperatures.
HCAs have been linked to various cancers, including stomach, colorectal,
pancreatic and breast cancers in humans.
Red meat
also contains high amounts of saturated fats, which have been shown to increase
the risk of heart disease.
In a related
study, published in the American Journal of Epidemiology, diets rich in
red meat were linked to age-related macular degeneration (AMD), the leading
cause of blindness in aging Americans. In the study, 6,734 people (aged 58-69)
completed food frequency questionnaires in 1990-1994. During the follow-up
period (2003-2006), the participants were monitored for the development of AMD.
The
researchers found that people who ate red meat 10 or more times per week were
47 percent more likely to develop AMD than those who ate it less then 4.5 times
per week. The authors suggest that these effects may be attributed to compounds
in the meat that cause oxidative damage.
Additional
research is needed to determine exactly how red meat might increase the risk of
AMD.
For more
information about different types of diets, please visit Natural Standard's Health
& Wellness database.