A
new study evaluated the health risks and benefits of estrogen and progestin
therapy and found an increased risk of fatal and nonfatal illnesses
(malignancies).
Researchers
from the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, reported that the Women's
Health Initiative (WHI) trial of estrogen plus progestin was stopped early,
after a mean of 5.6 years of follow-up, because the overall health risks of
hormone therapy exceeded its benefits.
The
study analyzed health outcomes three years (mean 2.4 years of follow-up) after
the intervention was stopped.
The
intervention phase was a double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized trial of estrogen
plus progestin (conjugated equine estrogens 0.625 milligrams daily plus
medroxyprogesterone acetate 2.5 milligrams daily) in 16,608 women aged 50-79
years. The post-intervention phase commenced July 8, 2002 and included 15,730
women.
The
primary end points were coronary heart disease and invasive breast cancer. A
global index summarizing the balance of risks and benefits included the two
primary end points plus stroke, pulmonary embolism, endometrial cancer,
colorectal cancer, hip fracture and death due to other causes.
The
study found that after the intervention, cardiovascular risk was comparable by
initial randomized assignments: 1.97 percent (annualized rate) in the hormone
therapy group (343 events) and 1.91 percent in the placebo group (323 events).
The
researchers observed a greater risk of malignancies in the estrogen plus progestin group than in the
placebo group (1.56 percent vs. 1.26 percent). More breast cancers were
diagnosed in women who had been randomly assigned to receive hormone therapy vs.
placebo (0.42 percent vs. 0.33 percent) with a modest trend toward a lower
hazard ratio during the follow-up after the intervention.
All-cause
mortality was somewhat higher in the estrogen plus progestin group than in the
placebo group (1.20 percent vs. 1.06 percent).
The
global index of risks and benefits was unchanged from randomization through
March 31, 2005, indicating that the risks of estrogen plus progestin therapy exceed the
benefits for chronic disease prevention, reported the researchers.
The
increased cardiovascular risks in the women assigned to hormone therapy during the intervention period
were not observed after the intervention.
The
study authors concluded that a greater risk of fatal and nonfatal malignancies
occurred after the intervention in the estrogen plus progestin group and the
global risk index was 12 percent higher in women randomly assigned to receive
conjugated equine estrogens plus medroxyprogesterone acetate compared with
placebo.
Integrative
therapies with good scientific evidence in the treatment of menopause include
calcium, sage and soy.
Calcium
is the nutrient consistently found to be the most important for attaining peak
bone mass and preventing osteoporosis. Adequate vitamin D intake is required
for optimal calcium absorption. Adequate calcium and vitamin D are deemed
essential for the prevention of osteoporosis in general, including
postmenopausal osteoporosis. There is a link between lower dietary intake of
calcium and symptoms of premenstrual syndrome. Calcium supplementation has been
suggested in various clinical trials to decrease overall symptoms associated
with PMS, such as depressed mood, water retention and pain.
Sage
(Salvia officinalis) may contain compounds with mild estrogenic
activity. In theory, estrogenic compounds may decrease the symptoms of
menopause. Sage has been tested against menopausal symptoms with promising
results.
Soy
(Glycine max) products containing isoflavones have been studied for the
reduction of menopausal symptoms such as hot flashes. The scientific evidence
is mixed in this area, with several human trials suggesting a reduced number of
hot flashes and other menopausal symptoms, but more recent research reporting
no benefits. Overall, the scientific evidence does suggest benefits, although
better quality studies are needed in this area in order to form a firm
conclusion.
Integrative
therapies with fair negative evidence in the treatment of menopause include
boron, evening primrose oil and wild yam.
Boron
is a trace mineral found in soil, water and some foods. It has been proposed
that boron affects estrogen levels in post-menopausal women. However,
preliminary studies have found no changes in menopausal symptoms.
Available
studies do not show evening primrose (Oenothera biennis) oil to be
helpful with these potential complications of menopause. Small human studies do
not report that evening primrose oil is helpful for the symptoms of PMS.
Despite
popular belief, no natural progestins, estrogens or other reproductive hormones
are found in wild yam. Its active ingredient, diosgenin, is not converted to
hormones in the human body. Artificial progesterone has been added to some wild
yam products. The belief that there are hormones in wild yam may be due to the
historical fact that progesterone, androgens and cortisone were chemically
manufactured from Mexican wild yam in the 1960s.